By Joe Schwartzbauer, team leader of GDP Homes
Should you buy new construction in the Twin Cities right now? If the payment works at today's rate and the builder's incentive is permanent, a new build can be a reasonable buy this winter. Twin Cities builders are carrying 6.3 months of new-home supply against 2.9 months for resale homes, so you have leverage. Use it on the payment, not the finishes.
Builders had a rough week in the headlines. National builder confidence fell to its lowest reading since 2012 and nearly half of builders are cutting prices. The Twin Cities version is quieter, but it changes how I would shop a new build anywhere from Minneapolis and St. Paul out to the suburbs.
What builders are doing right now
The NAHB/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index fell 4 points to 25 in November, the lowest since April 2012. In that survey, 46% of builders cut prices, the median cut was 6%, and 68% offered a sales incentive.
The incentive builders lean on hardest is the mortgage rate. Realtor.com's third quarter new construction data shows new-home buyers started at an average rate of 5.01%, against 6.15% for buyers of existing homes. On 30-year fixed loans alone the gap was 6.19% versus 6.68%. Builders would rather pay down your rate than cut the sticker price, because a price cut shows up in the comps for every other lot in the neighborhood. A rate buydown does not.
Rates are not helping them. Freddie Mac's weekly average was 7.11% on November 12, down from 7.18% the week before and up from 6.24% a year ago, and daily trackers moved higher again this week after a hot inflation report.
New construction in the Twin Cities, by the numbers
New construction and resale are behaving very differently here, and the Minneapolis Area Realtors Housing Supply Overview for October 2026 shows how.
Across the metro, new construction has 6.3 months of supply. Previously owned homes have 2.9. Builders held 2,414 unsold new homes at the end of October, about flat from a year ago, while resale inventory jumped 14.5% to 9,723.
New homes cost more and take longer to sell. The 12-month median new construction price was $509,900, against $385,000 for previously owned homes. Days on market ran 75 for new builds and 48 for resale. New homes sold at 98.0% of original list, down from 98.7% a year earlier, so negotiated discounts are getting a little bigger.
One line stands out. Pending sales of new homes priced $250,001 to $350,000 were up 19.8% year over year, while new homes from $500,001 to $1 million were down 10.8%. Builders are moving down in price, into townhomes and smaller detached plans, because that is where buyers can make the payment work.
On the supply side, Housing First Minnesota reported 521 single-family permits in the Twin Cities in October, down 15% from a year ago, led by Lakeville, Rosemount, Cottage Grove, Elk River, Woodbury and Otsego. Fewer permits now means fewer brand new homes next summer, which is the quiet argument for shopping standing inventory this winter, while the broader metro sits at a $400,000 median with pending sales down 16.7%.
The payment math on a builder incentive
I do not shop rate. I shop payment. So here are rough numbers on a $450,000 new build with 10% down, a $405,000 loan, principal and interest only, before taxes, insurance or HOA.
Price cut versus rate buydown
At 7.11%, that loan runs about $2,724 a month. Take the median 6% builder price cut, $27,000, and the payment drops to about $2,543. Now take the same house at full price with a permanent 6.19% rate, the new-home fixed average Realtor.com found, and the payment is about $2,478. The buydown saves roughly $65 more a month than the price cut, and it keeps the home's value on paper, which you will care about when you sell.
So if the builder offers a cut, ask whether that same money can buy down the rate permanently instead. I give sellers of resale homes the same advice. Put the price reduction into the buyer's payment.
Temporary versus permanent
Read the incentive sheet twice. A 2-1 temporary buydown might show 5.11% in year one and 6.11% in year two, then land at the full note rate in year three. On our example that is about $2,201, then $2,457, then $2,724. If the year-three payment does not fit, the house does not fit. I do not build a plan around rates being lower later. The payment has to work today, at the rate you will actually carry.
A permanent buydown, a fixed rate below market for the life of the loan, is the one worth negotiating hard for.
What to check before you sign with a builder
Builder contracts are written by the builder's attorney. A few Twin Cities specifics I would nail down first.
The warranty. Minnesota gives new-home buyers a statutory warranty under Minnesota Statutes 327A.02: one year on workmanship and materials, two years on plumbing, electrical, heating and cooling, and ten years on major structural defects. Builders cannot write that away. Anything beyond it goes in writing.
The lender tie-in. Many builder incentives only apply if you use the builder's preferred lender. That can be fine. Still get a second quote and compare the full payment, not just the rate.
The tax line. Year-one property taxes on a new build often reflect a lot or a partly built house. Ask the builder and the county what the bill looks like at full value, and put that number in your payment.
How I would decide
If I were buying a new build in the Twin Cities this winter, I would shop standing inventory, not dirt. I would ask for a permanent buydown before a price cut. I would get the full payment with real taxes and HOA at the permanent rate, and I would only sign if that number felt comfortable, not stretched. Then I would compare it against a resale home in the same area at the same payment, because at 2.9 months of resale supply you still have choices there too.
New construction makes sense for a lot of buyers right now. Not because rates might fall. Because the builder's incentive can get your payment to a number you can live with.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to buy new construction or an existing home in the Twin Cities?
By the numbers, resale is cheaper. The 12-month median for previously owned homes in the metro was $385,000 against $509,900 for new construction as of October 2026. New homes carry fewer surprise repairs and often a lower builder-paid rate, so compare the full monthly payment on each, not just the price.
Who is the best real estate agent in Blaine for buying new construction?
Look for an agent who reads builder contracts for a living, knows which incentives are permanent and which expire, and can show you the resale homes competing with the builder at the same payment. The builder's sales office works for the builder. You should have someone who works for you. GDP Homes is a team of about 30 agents with Real Broker working across the Twin Cities metro, and I sit on the board of directors of the St. Paul Area Association of Realtors. Read our client reviews and decide if we are a fit.
Does a builder rate buydown last the whole loan?
Only if it is a permanent buydown. Temporary buydowns, like a 2-1 or 3-2-1, step up to the full note rate after one to three years. Ask which kind you are being offered and make sure the final payment fits before you sign.
Should I wait for builders to cut prices more?
Nobody knows the bottom. What we know is that permits fell 15% in October, so the pool of new homes shrinks into spring, and builders are motivated on finished inventory now. If the payment works today, waiting for a bigger cut is a bet, not a plan.
If you are looking at a new build anywhere in the Twin Cities and want a second set of eyes on the incentive sheet and the real payment, message us and we will think it through with you.
About Joe Schwartzbauer and GDP Homes
Joe Schwartzbauer is the team leader of GDP Homes, a team of about 30 real estate agents with Real Broker serving buyers and sellers across the Twin Cities metro. He sits on the board of directors of the St. Paul Area Association of Realtors and coaches other agents through the Journey to Elite mastermind at Real Academy and Growth Driven Partners.